From the Fembrys encounter:

Fembrys' Cloak (radiates faint abjuration magic)

Fembrys' Holy Symbol (a faint trace of illusion on it)

Starry Gnosis (radiates moderate enchantment magic)

Fembrys' keys

From the dungeon

A missive which says: "The latest set of petitioners awaits disposition down in the river dungeon -Don't steal any of those for your sad hobby, Fembrys, or you'll find your own head on a wall." - it is signed "Arthas"

From the Arthas encounter

Heavy Mace (magical)

Full-Plate (magical)

Heavy Steel Shield (magical)

Cloak (magical)

Periapt (magical)

From the boatman encounter

Boatman's keys

553 GP

Golden Bracelet with engravings of wild mustangs galloping across the band

Circlet made of intertwining gold and silver

Dagger (magical)

3 apparently crudely made arrows (All radiating magical auras)

Hand drawn Map: http://www.dndonlinegames.com/showthread.php?p=2603613#post2603613

From Maximanus and Katrina

2000 GP (another 5000 upon completion of our task)

5 potions of maximized cure moderate wounds (2d8+10)